The Once Upon a Time season 1 finale is bringing back a number of iconic characters, but this particular return will perhaps be especially emotional for fans. Read showrunner Edward Kitsis’ hints about spoiler‘s return!

Amongst the returning stars are Kristin Bauer, Emilie de Ravin, and Sebastian Stan. But fans seem to be most excited about the sure to be emotional return of Jamie Dornan, who won our hearts (no pun intended) as Sheriff Graham/the Huntsman.

We have assumed that the actor would only be reprising his role as the Huntsman in a bittersweet flashback to the Fairytale world, seeing as his character is very much dead in Storybrooke – but perhaps there’s more to it! Edward Kitsis certainly suggests as much to TV Line, saying:

I can say that it is one my favorite reveals of the entire year, and to spoil it would be so heartbreaking.

What kind of reveal could Kitsis be talking about?! Our heads are spinning with theories (is Graham not really dead? Does magic bring him back to life? Did he return to the fairytale world when he died in Storybrooke?), but we want to hear what you guys think! So speculate away in the comments.

m4s0n501