A new episode of Supernatural airs tonight! The show finally returns from its hiatus with ‘Out With the Old.’ What manner of evil will the brothers face this week… and who’s that in the promo?!?

Tonight at 9/8c on The CW, Sam and Dean will be tracking down cursed objects sold from an antique store! The description reads:

Sam and Dean investigate after a ballerina dances herself to death, and their probe reveals that the ballet slippers the victim wore are cursed. When Dean accidentally touches them, the curse takes hold of him.

Watch the promo, but beware of a big spoiler!