The American Idol Top 4 saw the pool shrink by one tonight.

After Ryan Seacrest brought each contestant to the front of the stage only to send them all back to the couch (have too much time to fill? Geez…), it was Hollie Cavanagh who ended up receiving the lowest number of votes and was sent home.

The other three contestants – Phillip Phillips, Jessica Sanchez, and Joshua Ledet – are also heading home this week, but they’ll be only visiting for their respective homecoming parades.

Do you think Hollie was the right contestant to go home?

Jennifer Lopez and David Cook were tonight’s performers.