After killing one of her heretic family members, Damon and Stefan have to suffer Lily’s wrath on tonight’s episode of The Vampire Diaries.

Last week on The Vampire Diaries Stefan attempted to make a truce with Lily and her heretics. With the help of Matt and Caroline they cleared out the town and gave the territory to Lily, and in return she and her family members would leave them alone. However, Damon didn’t like this plan, and neither did Bonnie. Together they went out and they killed one of Lily’s heretics, and now they have to suffer the consequences.

The synopsis for tonight’s episode reads: “When an impulsive decision by Damon threatens to unravel a carefully negotiated deal between Stefan and Lily, he has no choice but to make amends with his mother before things spiral further out of control. However, Lily remains one step ahead and carries out a harsh plan that hits Damon where it hurts most. Elsewhere, after returning to Whitmore Collage, Alaric turns to Bonnie for help with a mysterious and potentially dangerous artifact he has obtained, while Matt is forced into making a risky life or death decision. Meanwhile, Caroline, who finds herself a pawn in Lily and the heretics’ plan for retribution, uncovers a shocking detail about Stefan’s past.”

What detail could Caroline uncover about Stefan that we don’t already know? There are so many possibilities, given that he has been alive for over a century. We just hope it’s a juicy secret and not something lame like having had a previous love or something.

We also have a bunch of stills for tonight’s episode! They show us a little of what’s going on, but not much more than the trailer. Let’s hope Caroline gets to keep her eyes – we’re not sure she could pull off an eyepatch.

‘The Vampire Diaries’ returns tonight at 8:00 p.m. Eastern!