A new report reveals that Weinstein Company and Miramax are looking to remake the ’90s classic She’s All That.

According to The Wrap, the film starring Freddie Prinze Jr., Paul Walker, and Rachael Leigh Cooke is about to be remade by director Kenny Leon.

While the studios are denying that The Wrap’s report is true, we have strong feelings about this idea. We asked two of the film’s biggest fans — who happen to be Hypable writers — about whether or not the She’s All That remake should happen:

Why they should remake it: Our culture is saturated with remakes feeding off of ’90s nostalgia, so if it HAS to happen, at least it’s happening with the best motion picture to come out of 1999 — no, I’m not talking about American Beauty, I obviously mean She’s All That. I’m extra excited because the remake is being directed by Kenny Leon and produced by Tonya Lewis Lee (Spike Lee’s wife). She’s All That is infamously criticized for perpetuating the white-washed high school and sassy black best friend tropes of the late ’90s, so with Leon and Lee at the helm, the remake should feature a much more diverse student body, and frankly, be much more culturally relevant than the original. – Ariana Quiñónez

Why they shouldn’t remake it: While I’m generally open-minded about remakes, the thought of She’s All That being remade makes me want to silently sob in a corner. She’s All That is THE teen romantic comedy. It’s the movie that other movies take inspiration from. In fact, you’ll be hard-pressed to find a teen rom-com that doesn’t have similar elements to She’s All That. Even if you’ve never seen the movie, you probably know the entire plot because you’ve seen it in other teen rom-coms (including Not Another Teen Movie, which essentially satirizes the whole movie). It’s iconic.

Remaking it would be like remaking The Breakfast Club. It just can’t happen. The cast (young Freddie Prinze, Jr., anyone?!) and ’90s feel is what makes it so charming and fun. Without these elements, the movie is simply a film that you’ve seen a thousand times over. For instance, the whole “ugly girl who’s actually pretty” trope pretty much started with this movie. Since the movie relies heavily on this trope, it’s not going to do well at this point in time; the trope is just so overused and outdated. To update the usage of the trope to give it a twist would essentially change the entire movie. So, if that’s what they’re going to do, why not just come up with an original script and LEAVE SHE’S ALL THAT ALONE? I just can’t get behind this. – Danielle Zimmerman

Your turn: Should ‘She’s All That’ receive a remake?

Hit the comments to sound off! Here’s the trailer for the original to remind you of its brilliance: