Let’s be honest. One of the greatest games to play while watching Scream is spotting all the resting creep faces that take place on the show.

But we want to know who you think gives the BEST creep face. Below are some examples of what exactly classifies as a resting creep face, and proof that not all creep faces are the same.

Noah Foster

Creepy classic.

Emma Duval

Even the most unlikely creepers can play the game.

Will Belmont

Creepy with a whiff of jealousy.

Audrey Jesen

Mad as hell AND creepy.

Kieran Wilcox

I’m coming for your girl creepy.

Brooke Maddox

Bitchy with a side of creep.

Jake Fitzgerald

All around creepy as shit.

Piper Shay

Enthusiastically creepy.

Mr. Branson

Intimidatingly creepy.

See?! The rainbow of creepiness is diverse on Scream and just about every variation of the behavior is present.

Below you can vote for your favorite, and in the comments you can tell us why you find that person to be the creepiest!

This week we also learned that Scream would be returning for a season two, which brings up a bunch of questions. How do you continue to write for a horror show that lasts more than 10 episodes long? Other shows have done it. Some more successfully than others. But what will Scream’s tactic be?

Will the story pick up where season one leaves off? Or perhaps we’ll get a whole new batch of creep faces in a completely different town. No word yet from the network as to what we should expect, but as soon as we learn more we’ll share it with you here.

For more Scream news, make sure to visit this page. And you can catch the show itself on MTV, Tuesdays at 10 p.m. ET.