After torturing fans with a Pretty Little Liars-less Tuesday last week, the show returns on ABC Family tonight at 8 p.m.!

Episode 3×05 “That Girl Is Poison” will likely be full of consequences, as we see more of the aftermath of Caleb and Hanna’s breakup and find out what sight means for Jenna. The girls believe that “A” will strike at Jenna’s birthday party, and according to the episode synopsis, “a heartbroken Hanna makes a shocking discovery.”

Watch the episode preview below, check out some of the spoiler-filled clips from “That Girl Is Poison” at this link, and return to this page after the episode to discuss your Pretty Little Liars theories with fellow fans!