In a new photoshoot for Elle magazine, Ryan Murphy cast the stars of his hit shows — Glee and American Horror Story — in scenes from his favorite scary movies. See Lea Michele in Creature from the Black Lagoon, Connie Britton in The Omen, Heather Morris in Repulsion and more after the jump![scrollGallery id=397 useCaptions=true autoScroll=false thumbsdown=true]

For Murphy’s description of each scene in the “Killer Fashion Shoot,” head over to Elle’s website!

Which of the horror movie-inspired photos is your favorite?