Last night, Hugh Jackman and Nick Offerman battled Susan Sarandon and Jimmy Fallon on “Password.”

Jimmy Fallon put together quite a team last night for the Tonight Show With Jimmy Fallon segment “Password.”

Related: Hugh Jackman is terrifying as Blackbeard in new Pan trailer

Steve Higgins hosted the mock quiz show, which saw the formidable Hugh Jackman team up with Parks and Rec alum Nick Offerman, to battle Fallon himself and Susan Sarandon!

Each player was given a “password” which they had to make their partner guess with only one word. Some words were harder than others, and Nick Offerman was — of course — a pro at this game, because Nick Offerman is a pro at everything.

Hugh Jackman was on the show to talk about Pan, the new Peter Pan origin story in which Jackman stars as the fearsome pirate Captain Blackbeard.

In another segment from last night’s episode of The Tonight Show With Jimmy Fallon, Jackman tried to convince Fallon that vegemite is actually edible (don’t kill us, Australian readers!), and even brought some out for him to try:

Spoiler alert: Fallon seemed to like it much more this time, but he might just be trying to spare Jackman’s feelings. By the way, is anyone else totally going to “toast” with their friends whenever they eat toast from now on?

Related: Here’s the alternate Thelma & Louise ending you never knew you always wanted

Susan Sarandon was promoting The Secret Life of Marilyn Monroe, while Nick Offerman was there to talk about his new book Gumption: Relighting the Torch of Freedom with America’s Gutsiest Troublemakers.