TV Line reports that a drama series on one of the big five networks (those are CBS, ABC, NBC, Fox, and The CW) is planning to kill its “star” character in its season finale at the end of the current season. Uh oh!

“I’m told the death will occur toward the end of the episode, which will leave just enough time for an emotional, season-ending cemetery scene in which [redacted] bids an emotional farewell to [redacted],” says TV Line. In addition, “the actor/actress in question has not yet been officially released from his/her contract, which has led some to speculate that the show could be setting up a Buffy-style bait and switch. A well-placed insider, however, maintains, ‘As it stands now, [redacted] is not returning next season.'”

So now the question is: Who the hell is it?! We asked Hypable’s staff to file their best guesses, and these are the conversations that followed in our private Facebook group:

Could it be someone on Once Upon a Time, like Robert Carlyle?

Or might it be someone on The 100 (which recently suffered a major loss)?

Or will it be one of the Castle leads?

Maybe someone will die on How to Get Away with Murder! Like Wes!

A couple of our writers couldn’t guess only one person. Brandi thought it could be Tom Selleck from Blue Bloods, Caroline from The Vampire Diaries, or Fitz from Scandal.

Or maybe it’s someone from… *deep breath* Blacklist, Limitless, Scorpion, The Good Wife, Quantico, Elementary, Mysteries of Laura (but don’t ask Brittany), Arrow, Grey’s Anatomy, or any of these other shows in this stream of conscious from Kristina:

Who do you think is getting ready to die?

Let us know who you think it is in the comments. It’ll be fun to look back!