It took us about four forking seconds to realize how many great shows were missing on Thursday’s list of Emmy nominations.

There’s a lot to like about the 2018 Emmy nominations. It’s thrilling to see Sandra Oh become the first ever Asian-American to be nominated for her fantastic work in Killing Eve. The nominations for The Americans — which wrapped up its astounding run with an equally astounding final season — are certainly well deserved. And the recognition for the Black led and produced storytelling of Insecure, Black-ish and Atlanta is definitely worth celebrating.

Yet for all that the Emmy nominations have given recognition for some fantastic tv shows, there is an equal — I might even venture to say greater — number of fantastic tv shows that were left off the list of nominations.

Here are the shows we’re shocked didn’t get more recognition on the Emmy nomination list — or got left off altogether.

The Good Place

While I’m thrilled that Ted Danson and Maya Rudolph were given a nod for their fantastic performances in The Good Place, I’m stunned and a little bit angry that the show as a whole didn’t get more recognition.

The entire cast is absolutely fantastic, but I especially would’ve loved a nomination for either Jameela Jamil or D’Arcy Carden in the supporting actress category because they do absolutely tremendous work with their characters.

The show itself likewise should have been nominated in the best comedic show category, as it is not only consistently clever and laugh out loud funny, but also heartwarming, genuine and thoughtful. The lack of nominations for this last season surely means that we’re in The Bad Place (or at least in A Medium Place).

One Day at a Time

The fact that One Day at a Time didn’t get any nominations is the single most ridiculous thing about the 2018 Emmys. Seriously, One Day at a Time could’ve been nominated solely on the strength of episode 2×09 — “Hello, Penelope” — alone, as it is one of the most evocative, impactful and important episodes of television that I’ve ever had the privilege of watching.

The entire cast is fantastic and should’ve all gotten nods to their performances, but at the very least I would’ve settled for seeing both Rita Moreno and Justina Machado being nominated for supporting and lead actress in a comedy, respectively. Episode after episode, these two ladies manage to make me laugh out loud and weep uncontrollably with their performances and the show as a whole is a well-written, bright, sunny spot of hope in a world that feels increasingly dark.

One Day at a Time not only proves that family-centered, multicam sitcoms are worth making, but that they’re just what we need and want on our tv screens.

Brooklyn 99

Yes, Brooklyn 99 has been nominated in the past, and yes, it was nominated this year in the guest actor spot. But here are two reasons I’m putting it on this list: Andre Braugher wasn’t on the list for best supporting actor in a comedy, and Andre Braugher has never won for his role as Captain Ray Holt. Yes, he’s been nominated before, and yes, he’s won Emmys for other roles. But he has never won an Emmy for what is probably the greatest and most surprising character in a show riddled with great and surprising characters. Seriously, episode 4×08 — where Holt yells “BONE?!” over and over again — should’ve basically just ensured that he win in this category. And not just this year, but every year until Brooklyn 99 gets permanently cancelled.

Jane the Virgin

The CW’s first ever Golden Globe winning show should also be its first ever Emmy award winning show.

Jane the Virgin just wrapped up its fourth season and has managed to not only have an incredibly shocking and emotional season finale, but to also maintain consistently high quality throughout its four year run. You could throw a dart in the general cast’s direction and, no matter what, you’d hit someone who definitely deserves to be nominated.

I will say that if I absolutely had to pick just one, it would be Andrea Navedo, who was stunning in her performance as Xo this last season. The only reason I’ll accept the lack of nominations this year is if the academy is waiting until the fifth and final season to give Jane the Virgin all the awards. It’s what the show deserves.

Will and Grace

The foursome ensemble that make up Will and Grace all delivered some great scenes over the course of the show’s revival. And kudos to Megan Mullally for picking up her well-deserved nomination.

However, there was one actor who was having the comedic run of his life week in and week out. Sean Hayes’ return as Jack McFarland not only ran circles around almost every scene of his original run, but elevated the bar for not only himself, but anyone still willing to make a pratfall funny on prime time television.

Even with six nominations and one win under his belt, Sean Hayes sang the song (and did the dance) to prove that some revivals are worth it.

The Expanse

Even though genre shows are getting a bit more recognition than they have in the past, the Emmys still tend to ignore any that play on smaller networks. Which is such a damn shame, because The Expanse had such a fantastic second season and I would’ve loved to see it get the recognition that it so deserves.

It’s a space opera on the scale of Battlestar Galactica, has the great political storytelling of Emmy darling Game of Thrones without all the rape and general violence towards women, and has some of the best worldbuilding I’ve ever seen on television. If the academy wasn’t going to give a nod to the show as a whole, I’d at least have loved for them to nominate Shohreh Aghdashloo for her work as snarky U.N.N leader and all-around badass Chrisjen Avasarala.

The Americans

The big four — Keri Russell, Matthew Rhys, and Joel Fields and Joe Weisberg — all picked up well-deserved Emmy nominations for their final season. But Noah Emrich, who plays FBI agent/the Jennings’ next door neighbor for the entire run of the series fell short of picking up a supporting actor nom. Why? Stan’s final few episode of the series allowed him to play the best and worst of Stan. The payoff of reaching the inevitable conclusion of his storyline was crushing in his final moments on screen. It’s sad to see this season, and his collective work on The Americans go unrecognized.

Star Trek: Discovery

Sound editing and prosthetics aside, Star Trek: Discovery is lacking in the nominations department. The series’ actors were notably excluded, especially Sonequa Martin-Green as Michael Burnham and Michelle Yeoh as Captain Georgiou and later Emperor Georgiou. The former walked the line of playing a human at constant conflict with her Vulcan upbringing with such conviction you too didn’t know where to place your emotions. The latter puts to good use her martial arts training to beat up on Jason Isaacs in the season 1 finale, which was both badass to witness and hard not to root for. Both of these women led the latest Trek with such force that the anticipation for season 2 is almost unbearable.