Tonight, American Idol narrowed their top 13 down to a top 12. Do you think the person that was eliminated should have been?
Tonight, the bottom 3 girls were Elise, Shannon and Erica.
The bottom 3 guys were Jermaine, Jeremy and Joshua.
After the bottom guys and bottom girls were announced, they were narrowed down to the bottom guy and bottom girl: Jeremy and Elise.
Of the bottom 2, it was up to the judges to decide who would stay on the show and which 1 of the 2 would be going home.
After deliberation Jeremy was eliminated from the show.
Do you think America and the judges made the right decision in sending Jeremy home?