Tonight, American Idol narrowed its top six to a top five after the nationwide vote. Was the right contestant sent packing? Find out who went home and sound off in our comments section.

Tonight, after performances by Katy Perry and season 10 finalist Stefano Langone, it was announced that Elise Testone was eliminated from the competition.

Do you think Elise should have been eliminated tonight compared to the other five contestants’ performances?

Let us know what you think in the comments below as well as who you think will be taking the season 11 Idol crown this year!