Avengers: Endgame has a few plot problems. That is really not a problem.
This article contains major spoilers for Avengers: Endgame. Proceed with caution.
As the initial high of Marvel’s capstone achievement, Avengers: Endgame, begins to ebb just a bit, the internet has filled with analysis and questions.
There are other questions too; the twists and turns of the time travel plot line, which takes up considerable space in the film, has left some fans probing for explanations.
If changing the past doesn’t change the future, why couldn’t someone go back and save Natasha? Is Loki’s vanishing with the Tesseract meant to suggest that he survives? How can that be possible if Captain America returned the stones to their proper places in time? And if Cap did return the stones, how could he live out his life with Peggy and return to the present as an old man?
I understand why these questions exist. But the thing is, the answers to this kind of question… don’t matter.
There is a major mistake people make when they analyze Avengers: Endgame, and indeed, the greater Marvel Cinematic Universe. (And honestly, a significant chunk of speculative fiction in general.) That being that Endgame, and the MCU, and so many stories like it belong to the genre of science fiction.
Being science fiction, it is assumed, these stories are therefore beholden to the demands of that genre. Demands like scientific consistency and rational consequences to impossible scenarios, like Primer-esque time travel that holds up under the scrutiny of billions of fan analyses.
That’s wrong, for one reason:
Marvel is not science fiction
Marvel is not science fiction.
And not being science fiction, it is not beholden to the demands of that genre.
Now that that’s out of the way, let me back up for a second.
For a long time, the distinction between science fiction and fantasy has been reduced to what amounts to so much literary set design. The scenery, props, and costumes of a story have been allowed to stand-in for the natures of the stories they belong to. Genre has been conflated with creative mechanism.
If you’ve got blasters and ray guns, it’s science fiction. Swap those out for magic wands, and we’re working with fantasy. Elves and dragons belong to fantasy, aliens and mad inventors to science fiction. Your story is set in a space ship? Sci-fi. Your story is set in a castle? Fantasy.
But this is an inherently superficial kind of classification. It’s imposed from the outside in, based on what a story looks like rather than what it is. That’s not to say that the particular tools of a tale have no influence on (or can’t be the products of) genre — obviously, they can be and often are. But these accouterments are secondary considerations.
Far, far more important to genre are the interests and values of the story itself.
Does the story prioritize character (fantasy) or does it highlight and interrogate plot and concept (science fiction)? Do the story’s values live in the realm of emotion and experience (F), or intellect and ideology (SF)? Is the creator working with the primary interests of fantasy or science fiction, not to design their world, but to define it?
Like so much else in life, genre is a spectrum, not a binary. Many stories — an increasing number of stories, actually — exist in between the absolute poles of “hard” science fiction and fantasy. The Marvel Cinematic Universe is among them, a potent example of the delights of putting your wizards in laboratories and calling your aliens gods.
“Magic is just science we don’t understand yet,” Dr. Jane Foster argues in the first Thor movie. But in the MCU, it’s quite the opposite; science is simply magic that comes from a test tube.
Gamma rays, Vibranium, arc reactors, and yes, Pym Particle Time Travel and all of its convolutions — these props of themselves are not at all important to the story. They could as easily be a werewolf bite, mithril, a Time Turner. The MCU is not concerned with scientific integrity or realism; it is interested in interrogating what this magic-dressed-up-as-science does to its characters and the world they live in.
What’s more important about Captain America — the details of the super-soldier serum that made him, or what it means for a sickly man to be given a body to match his lion’s heart? What’s more important about Wakanda’s trove of Vibranium — the facts of the metal, or the impact it has on a country and people surrounded by colonization?
The tools used by the MCU may belong to science fiction. But its goals — character, social commentary, personal dramas — are those of fantasy.
And that’s why the inexactness, inconsistencies, and even outright flaws in Endgame‘s time travel narrative are immaterial to the success of the story. There’s a reason why the film makes direct references to movies like Back to the Future, a fantasy disguised as science fiction if ever there was one. In Endgame, the demands (and even the potential) of science always give way to the story’s emotional needs.
Natasha’s sacrifice is a crucial tragic beat; no take-backs allowed for her, or Frigga, or Iron Man. Nebula’s unexplained mind-meld sets the table perfectly for Thanos’ invasion, ultimately resolving her inner conflict. Even Loki’s disappearance is a letter-perfect character moment that loses the point if it’s overthought.
And yes, in that context it makes beautiful emotional sense for Steve to return to Peggy Carter’s side and live out his life with her. It doesn’t matter what year he went back to, or what that means for the exact placement of which Infinity Stones in time. What’s important is that Steve’s arc ended in the fulfillment of the one, pure thing he seemed doomed to be denied. That his reward was not 70 extra years, or a powerful body, or even saving the world.
Steve lived his life the way he’d hoped. He left the game, passed the torch. It wasn’t glorious or glamorous or well-known; it was just a simple life with the woman he loved.
As a man, not an Avenger, Steve Rogers left the Shire for the Grey Havens. He took the forward path through Harry’s King’s Cross Station. He may have used a time machine to get there, but he wound up in Narnia nevertheless.
It’s an ending that doesn’t work in a science fiction story. I won’t contest that; too many questions and loose ends. But as the ending moments of a fantasy — and Avengers: Endgame, and the Marvel Cinematic Universe are fantasy — it could not be more perfect.
Sometimes, the only remedy to a bad day is by isolating yourself on the couch and watching a guilty pleasure show, and luckily for us, Netflix has several great options.
Jessica is finally starting to "give a shit," and we ramp up the noir bigtime.
There’s no such thing as the wrong time to celebrate great movie dads, but with Father’s Day right around the corner, now is the perfect time! Check out our list of the 10 greatest movie dads of all time.
Universal Orlando has relied on big screens and motion simulation for its two marquee Wizarding World of Harry Potter rides, but its third, Hagrid’s Magical Creatures Motorbike Adventure, rewrites the script.
With the release of Aladdin and the live-action remake of The Lion King right around the corner, we rank the best (and worst) of the Disney remakes so far.
Get ready to rage out with Aggretsuko, an anime about dreams, reality, and aggression that is hilariously relatable to office workers.
Halfway through Toy Story 4, I realized that I had a slight problem. I’d been sent to review it but I got so wrapped up in the movie itself that I wasn’t looking at it critically. Then again, I guess that tells you everything about how much I enjoyed Toy Story 4.
We caught up with the Try Guys to discuss their new book The Hidden Power of F*cking Up, as well as their tour and what we can expect from them going forward.
Waiting for Tom Hanks is a great way to introduce your friends, family, and even the most casual rom com fan in your life to a wonderful world of books they may have been hesitant to consider before.