Join us as we discuss Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 1, episode 9, “Puppet Show,” and episode 10, “Nightmares.”

Superfans: Karen and Caitlin
Newbies: Brittany and Ariana

Fun Facts:
Clowns creep into Brittany’s dreams, Ariana has some 90s flashbacks to Nick’s Are You Afraid of the Dark‘s dollhouse episode, Caitlin has not gotten over her fear of being late for college softball, Karen had a severe Batman-inspired dream, but she also is afraid of missing the bus.

A note on spoilers

PSA: We are going to do our best and try and pay more attention to letting things slip that may unintentionally spoil the Buffy experience.

Now back to your regularly scheduled programming…

Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 1, episode 9, “Puppet Show”:
-Nostalgic fear is in full affect
-Creepy, yet hilarious puppetry
-“Flutie, come back!”
-Maybe the school needs a Principal Snyder
-Cordelia: watching her now versus watching Cordelia then
-Is it really so crazy for Buffy to think that the puppet is the cause of this entire scenario?
-Doesn’t your library have a section on dolls and humans?
-The magician was the key!
-Superfans can still be pleasantly surprised because this is not on the top of anyone’s rewatch list
-What is the difference between a demon hunter and a vampire slayer?
-Karen and Caitlin practice avoiding spoilers
-Favorite Scenes
-Favorite Quotes

Buffy the Vampire Slayer season 1, episode 10, “Nightmares”:
-Nightmares: let’s break them down
-Did we think the dream of the Master real?
-Buffy’s home life gets some focus in this episode which is refreshing
-The nightmare that comes to life was worse than Buffy fighting demons
-Buffy as a vampire, could they have gone further with it?
-What are Angel’s nightmares?
-No clowns. Ever.
-Willow, the show must go on!
-Giles’ fear are hilarious and also slightly depressing
-Fake-Joseph Gordon Levitt is responsible for everyone’s nightmares
-Freaky things go down on the Hellmouth
-This is a supernatural show that is dealing with actual people committing crimes and not just monsters
-Favorite Scenes
-Favorite Quotes

Listener Feedback:
-Rate us five-stars and get your own horny puppet from Karen!
-Yes, there are other Buffy podcasts. But do they have our pizazz?
-Welcome back listeners!
-We’re sorry you had to rewatch the puppet episode, but we made it through!
-Smell your book, people. Computers don’t smell.

Contact us!

Email: [email protected]
Twitter: @Re_Watchable
Tumblr: ReWatchablePodcast.Tumblr.com
Or in the comments below.
Please rate and review us on iTunes!

If there are any issues downloading this episode from iTunes, please refer to this guide.